Friday, March 13, 2009

VIDEO: Michael Steele Debate: 'I hope he stays around forever,' 'He's great for comic relief.'

Faiz Shakir of ThinkProgress and Amanda Carpenter debate the Michael Steele controversy.

Neither thinks Steele is doing a very good job. Carpenter calls Steele's abortion stance "muddled" and "problematic" for his future as the GOP leader.

Shakir slams Steele hard several times! Ouch!

For the record, David Shuster is a liberal Marxist and Sarah Palin hater .

Stumble Upon Toolbar submit to reddit

1 comment:

  1. I think Steele's stumbles, while different in form from Sarah Palin's unsuccessful broadcast-network interviews (he's said too much; she didn't say enough ... and was tongue-tied doing it), reflect a similar underlying difficulty - the attempt to brazen through an intellectual vacuum with charisma alone. Both Steele and Palin are extremely charismatic, as American politicians go, which is a big reason why Republicans of different stripes - moderates for the Marylander, conservatives for the Alaskan - have been so excited about them. But they've both attempted (or been asked) to chart a new direction for the Right on style alone, and they've floundered as soon as they've been pressed for substance. Steele has responded by telling his interlocutors whatever they want to hear, Palin responded by telling her interlocutors next to nothing at all - and the results, in both cases, are and were unfortunate.

    The point isn't that a brilliant rat-a-tat-tat of bright policy ideas from either Steele or Palin's lips would suddenly convert an audience of fence-sitting voters to rock-ribbed conservatism. It's that given conservatism's current straits, having something intelligent and fresh-sounding to say about how your political persuasion bears on the great issues of the day ought to be a baseline for rising right-of-center politicians. Insufficient, yes, but necessary all the same - not least because if you haven't figured out something smart-sounding to say in advance, all the charisma in the world won't save you from saying something foolish.